Can a thinner magnet make a propulsion motor lighter?
For an aircraft, a lighter propulsion unit can leave more mass available for payload or energy storage. Thinner magnets could help, but less magnetic flux can mean more current and heat at the same torque. Any saving has to survive the copper, cooling and retention needed around the magnet.
We use a to investigate how magnet thickness, rotor steel and winding choices interact. With the propeller and transmission fixed, the motor has to deliver the same shaft torque and speed.
We show the calculations, the checks that challenged them and the measurements that could change what we develop next.
In this notebook
Does thinning save mass at the same output?
Removing magnet material saves rotor mass. Does that saving survive the extra current, copper, cooling and retention the motor may need?
What must the magnet deliver when hot?
How much magnetic strength and resistance to demagnetization does the motor need at operating temperature? Can available magnets provide both?
Does a fault change the material requirement?
A short circuit changes the field opposing the magnets. Could it set a tighter requirement, and does changing the winding change that exposure?
Is a new material the right next step?
Could an available finished magnet or a different ring-and-winding combination meet the need? Which measurement would tell us where development should begin?
We modeled the reference in two dimensions, with assumed steel properties, windings and fault conditions.
Extra copper can outweigh the magnet’s mass saving.
Thinning the magnet from 1.5 to 1.0 mm takes 8.5 g out of the rotor. A thinner magnet also drives less flux across the air gap, so holding the same torque takes 11.5% more current.1 Copper loss grows with the square of current. Keeping it at the original level takes enough extra copper to outweigh the magnet material removed. Rotor and copper end up 4.0 g heavier.
Where the thinner magnet’s mass saving goes.
A 1.0 mm magnet against the 1.5 mm reference, with the original assumed ring.
The ring behind the magnets carries flux between poles. In our assumed steel curves, the electrical steel saturates less readily than the stainless steel, so the motor needs less current at either magnet thickness. Keeping the original magnet then saves more mass than thinning it.2
With the alternative steel, keeping the original magnet saves more mass.
On the alternative steel, the original magnet’s lower current allows either 5.1 g less copper at equal loss, or 19 W less copper loss with the original winding (20 °C resistance).
Why the winding belongs in the mass balance
Gemini 4 ArgonEarlier general review of component mass
Magnet and magnetic-circuit changes can enable lower surrounding steel, copper, or cooling mass even when current or copper heating binds.
GPT 6 AstraOriginal magnet with the alternative ring
If we retain the existing winding instead, that thicker-magnet alternative produces approximately 19 W less copper heat at the reference resistance, with no direct modeled mass saving. We cannot count both the full heat benefit and the copper removal.
The alternative ring lets us use less copper or generate less heat. The ledger counts the copper reduction at equal loss. Cooling and installation still have to fit within the remaining mass budget.
Expand for Assumptions
The target is the model's 3.0445 N m mean torque, sampled over four rotor positions. It is a selected comparison load, not a measured continuous rating. The geometry derives from the , with 36 slots, 42 poles, a 10 mm stack and a 0.7 mm air gap.
At fixed turns, conductor length and copper temperature, equal copper loss requires copper mass to scale with squared current. It does not preserve hotspot temperature or transient thermal capacity. The steel laws are generic assumptions. Mechanical retention, cooling, losses, voltage headroom and production variation remain outside this mass comparison.
Current is peak ampere-turns per coil. With 25 turns per coil, 300 A-turns means 12 A peak phase current; it is not line RMS. Methods and inputs / Direct-solve report
A stronger magnet also needs to resist demagnetization.
A thinner magnet needs more remanence to produce the same torque per ampere. Remanence is the flux density remaining after the magnetizing field is removed. The magnet also has to resist the stator’s opposing field; beyond the knee of its curve, some magnetization is lost permanently.3 Both properties fall with temperature, and gaining one often costs some of the other. The figure compares three published specimens at 100 °C, including two made without heavy rare earths (HRE-free).
A quick picture of the magnetic knee
Strength and resistance to demagnetization are different properties.
Magnetic strength and the knee at 100 °C.
To keep a saving under ordinary load, a specimen has to sit right of the dashed line and above the solid one.
The dashed line compares with the original reference before installation, not with the original magnet on the alternative ring. The solid line covers ordinary load only. Neither is a qualified requirement.
What can we buy before developing something new?
Figure 03 shows historical specimens, not today’s catalog. Two suppliers now list HRE-free grades. We have no hot finished-part data for either.
Bomatec N-52SH
The HRE-content sheet, p. 2 lists N-52SH as Dy/Tb/Ho/Gd-free.
We haven’t confirmed that its generic grade curves apply to this formulation.
CIBAS REN52SH Pure
The June 2026 catalog, p. 2 offers Pure grades excluding Dy/Tb/Ho/Gd through REN52SH.
CIBAS also lists a formulation containing Ho/Gd but no Dy/Tb. The catalog's general HRE-free definition is HRE content below 0.1%.
We haven’t qualified either route, and a missing public guarantee does not show a missing capability. Composition, hot finished-part performance, batch consistency, origin, orderability and procurement compliance each need their own check. Source update and limits.
Why we paused the proposed materials experiment
GPT 6 AstraThe proposed direction
The strongest hypothesis worth testing is a thin, HRE-free finished magnet that retains high hot remanence while gaining demagnetization resistance through grain-boundary processing.
GPT 6 AstraAfter checking existing supply
Existing HRE-free grades are credible enough that we should pause the proposed materials experiment. Our three-specimen comparison did not establish an industry capability gap. I moved too quickly from that comparison to grain-boundary development.
The next question became whether an available finished magnet, with a different ring and winding, could deliver the required performance. Hot finished-part data can distinguish a need for material development from a finishing or integration problem.
The winding matters during a fault, too.
A short circuit turns the spinning motor into a generator feeding its own winding. The current creates a field that opposes the magnets. Our first screen assumed twice the steady short-circuit current. Solving the field and winding circuit together gives a reverse-field estimate of 540–587 kA/m for the reference motor at three selected speeds.4
The fault calculation changes our estimate of the opposing field.
Reference motor reverse field at the most loaded 1% of magnet (kA/m).
The dashed marker shows ordinary load alone at 532 kA/m.
Why peak current alone cannot set the magnet requirement
GPT 6 AstraAfter solving the fault through time
The five-rotor comparison is showing why a single current multiplier was inadequate. The field distribution and which magnet locations experience the peak matter as much as the peak current.
Claude Opus 5.5Earlier review of field exposure in a different motor
It is an exposure diagnostic, not a defeat condition; I had overstated it as one. Whether the magnet survives needs a measurement of the finished part's hot recoil and history after machining and coating.
We now retain each magnet location’s worst exposure before ranking the whole magnet. This corrects the field statistic, but calculated exposure is not measured irreversible damage.
Material-history and instantaneous field resultsNumerical checks and limits
Explore all 32 recorded faults and their time traces
Follow a recorded fault through time.
Case ID sus15_2000_n8The dashed line retains each piece of magnet’s largest field from the whole event, then ranks the pieces. The blue line ranks them again at each instant. The two differ because the most exposed piece can change with time.
Inspect all 32 recorded cases and assumptions
All cases assume isolated-neutral star windings, prescribed speed and linear magnet recoil. Connected trace segments join recorded steps.
Scroll horizontally to see all columns.
| Case / rotor | Conditions | Event field (kA/m) | Peak phase current (A) |
|---|---|---|---|
sus15_450_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 300 A-turns before fault | 540 | 12.0 |
refine_sus15_1000_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 300 A-turns before fault | 549 | 14.1 |
pilot_sus15_1000_n4 | coarser mesh/time step0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 300 A-turns before fault | 549 | 14.0 |
sus15_1000_n16 | finest mesh/time step0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 300 A-turns before fault | 549 | 14.2 |
sus15_1000_n4_7cycles | 7 electrical periods; coarser mesh/time step0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 300 A-turns before fault | 549 | 14.0 |
sus15_2000_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 300 A-turns before fault | 587 | 20.1 |
sus15_2000_endL025 | 0.25 mH end inductance0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 300 A-turns before fault | 562 | 16.6 |
sus15_2000_hotwinding | 100 °C winding1.175 Ω, 1.250 T, 100 °C winding, 300 A-turns before fault | 564 | 17.8 |
sus15_2000_noload_corrected | no-load start0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 0 A-turns before fault | 583 | 18.6 |
sus15_2000_phase4 | 15° later fault start0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 300 A-turns before fault | 588 | 20.0 |
sus15_2000_phase8 | 30° later fault start0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 300 A-turns before fault | 587 | 19.3 |
sus10_1000_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 334 A-turns before fault | 621 | 13.4 |
sus10_2000_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 334 A-turns before fault | 667 | 17.7 |
steel15_1000_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 285 A-turns before fault | 532 | 14.7 |
steel15_1000_n4 | coarser mesh/time step0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 285 A-turns before fault | 533 | 14.6 |
steel10_1000_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 317 A-turns before fault | 614 | 12.9 |
steel10_2000_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 317 A-turns before fault | 670 | 18.0 |
steel10_2000_n4 | coarser mesh/time step0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 317 A-turns before fault | 669 | 17.9 |
steel10_2000_n8_r2 | finer radial mesh0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 317 A-turns before fault | 669 | 17.9 |
steel10_2000_rewound | copper resized for equal loss0.801 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 317 A-turns before fault | 681 | 18.7 |
steel10_2000_n4_7cycles | 7 electrical periods; coarser mesh/time step0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 317 A-turns before fault | 669 | 17.9 |
steel10_45SH_hot_2000_rewound | 1.227 T remanence; copper resized for equal loss; 100 °C winding1.018 Ω, 1.227 T, 100 °C winding, 322 A-turns before fault | 646 | 16.8 |
sus_thickring_1000_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 278 A-turns before fault | 532 | 14.9 |
sus_thickring_1000_n4 | coarser mesh/time step0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 278 A-turns before fault | 531 | 14.7 |
halbach_sus15_1000_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 281 A-turns before fault | 1148 | 14.4 |
halbach_sus15_1000_n4 | coarser mesh/time step0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 281 A-turns before fault | 1268 | 14.3 |
halbach20_1000_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 269 A-turns before fault | 1007 | 16.2 |
halbach20_2000_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 269 A-turns before fault | 1014 | 22.9 |
halbach20_2000_n4 | coarser mesh/time step0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 269 A-turns before fault | 1082 | 22.7 |
halbach20_2000_rewound | copper resized for equal loss1.115 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 269 A-turns before fault | 1013 | 20.8 |
halbach15_1000_n8 | Reference load and fault settings0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 313 A-turns before fault | 1007 | 13.6 |
halbach15_1000_n4 | coarser mesh/time step0.894 Ω, 1.250 T, 20 °C winding, 313 A-turns before fault | 1082 | 13.4 |
The added copper also lowers winding resistance, which can raise fault current. For the thin magnet on the alternative ring at 2,000 rpm, the equal-loss rewind raises the reverse-field estimate from 670 to 681 kA/m.
The segmented rotors’ local fields kept changing under mesh refinement, so we reject those thresholds. An earlier blind test of torque and voltage on two other motors failed, and a separate fixture comparison was inconclusive. We still haven’t validated the motor's internal fields.
Inspect the refinement and validation checks
Refining the mesh and time step barely moved the fault current. In the segmented rotors it moved the local field 7–10%, beyond the frozen 3% limit, so we can’t use those values as exact field thresholds.
Current can converge while the local field still changes.
Change on refinement (%). The local field is the quantity the magnet has to survive.
All nine refinement comparisons, including failures
Scroll horizontally to see all columns.
| Coarser → finer case | Current change | Field change | Criterion |
|---|---|---|---|
pilot_sus15_1000_n4 | 1.10% | 0.01% | Within 3% |
refine_sus15_1000_n8 | 0.43% | 0.03% | Within 3% |
sus_thickring_1000_n4 | 0.97% | 0.10% | Within 3% |
steel15_1000_n4 | 1.05% | 0.05% | Within 3% |
halbach15_1000_n4 | 1.28% | 7.50% | Failed 3% |
halbach_sus15_1000_n4 | 1.10% | 10.44% | Failed 3% |
steel10_2000_n4 | 0.42% | 0.22% | Within 3% |
halbach20_2000_n4 | 0.86% | 6.76% | Failed 3% |
steel10_2000_n8 | 0.07% | 0.09% | Within 3% |
The fixture’s point estimates passed. The band was too wide.
Drop in gap field under opposing current (mT). Shading is an assumed sensitivity band, not a confidence interval. Symbols are separated vertically for clarity.
Both meet their central-point tolerances.
Fails the 60 mT width limit.
This check was inconclusive. It does not replace the failed blind torque/voltage test on two other motors or validate the motor’s internal reverse field. Now that its results are released, it cannot serve as a new blind test.
Inspect the predictions, readings and sensitivity bands
Scroll horizontally to see all columns.
| Opposing current | Predicted drop | Measured drop | Sensitivity band | Width criterion |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2000 A-turns | 138.7 mT | 144.4 mT | 97.6–182.5 mT | Not tested |
| 4000 A-turns | 277.5 mT | 295.8 mT | 195.3–365.1 mT | Failed |
An independent validation agent selected the published fixture, withheld its outcomes from the builder and froze the criteria before predictions. The fixture checks reversible gap field; it does not validate hot NdFeB, irreversible damage or the motor's internal fields.
A simplified axial calculation gives about 6% less received flux in one 10 mm geometry; it is not a correction factor for this motor. A separate conducting-ring calculation passed numerical controls but could not resolve its field effect under its frozen criterion. Its outcome is also inconclusive.
Independent scientific review / Fault refinement review / Full scientific closure
Toward a lighter propulsion unit
The investigation made the material requirement more specific. A useful magnet has to stay strong at operating temperature, resist the opposing fields it meets under load and during a fault, and not cost more in copper, cooling and retention than it saves.
Catalog grades may meet the magnetic requirement on paper. The open question is the finished part. If hot magnetic performance limits the design, comparing a finished magnet arc with a parent sample from the same batch at operating temperature can separate a material limitation from changes introduced during processing. If current or heat rejection limits it, measuring the assembled motor at matched output may tell us more first.
That evidence decides whether we develop the material, the finishing process or the way the component is integrated. If you’re interested in pursuing these open questions with us, reach out. We’d love to chat.
Data, methods and checks.
The figures use the original calculation tables. Both scientific snapshots are preserved, including failed runs and the criteria used to judge them.
Methods and checks
Methods are plain-text Markdown; their relative paths refer to the original scientific record.
Sources, rights and reuse
INCLUDED as derived geometry and outputs. Digital files permitted with attribution; source files not included.
Koo and Shin 2026 prototype measurements
INCLUDED. Table measurements permitted with attribution; extracted numeric rows included.
GKN permanent magnet performance guide
SELECTED NUMERICAL OBSERVATIONS INCLUDED; full curve dataset withheld. PDF plot artwork and full digitized curves not redistributed; broader reuse unresolved.
Dynamical public-reference code and calculations
INCLUDED. Corrected solver and retained numeric outputs included.
Sjokvist and Eriksson2014 public author postprint
SELECTED NUMERICAL OBSERVATIONS INCLUDED. PDF, page images and full vector plot are not redistributed.
Our code, calculations and presentation are identified as Dynamical's work, shared for inspection; this page does not grant a blanket license over the package. Third-party measurements and documents retain their own terms. Supplier PDFs, full curves and source artwork are not redistributed. Complete source-rights register.
Failed checks and limits on our claims
- A thinner magnet necessarily makes the installed unit lighter.
- The doubled-current case is a predicted or guaranteed fault transient.
- Stable torque/current alone validates local magnet field.
- A 1% field-exposure screen predicts 1% irreversible flux loss.
- The simplified axial ratio is a correction factor for the native motor.
- The selected typical curves are finished-part, batch, domestic-origin or procurement guarantees.
- A failed field refinement proves the physical construction infeasible.
- The new fixture comparison validates the native motor or repairs the original failed two-motor evaluation.
- Equal copper heat establishes equal hotspot temperature after changing conductor mass.
The archive preserves the original failed two-prototype evaluation, the failed no-load attempt and its separate repaired rerun, and the failed segmented-field refinements.