# Existing supply changes the next question

Public-source update, checked 11 November 2026. This accompanies the frozen scientific record; it does not replace its inputs, outcomes or failed evaluations. No supplier was contacted and no physical measurement was performed.

The three historical specimens plotted in the notebook illustrate a joint remanence/knee tradeoff. They do not establish the limit of available HRE-free material. Two supplier documents identify routes worth checking before developing a new material.

| Route | Public evidence | What it does not establish |
|---|---|---|
| Bomatec N-52SH | The manufacturer's [HRE-content sheet](https://api.bomatec.com/uploads/Bomatec_AG_Nd_Fe_B_HRE_Content_14_11_2025_c12697c4cb.pdf), page 2, lists N-52SH as Dy/Tb/Ho/Gd-free. | The exact formulation's hot knee and recoil response in the required finished arc, repeatability, current orderability or production origin. Its [generic BMN-52SH sheet](https://api.bomatec.com/uploads/BMN_52_SH_1000cefbdc.pdf) describes idealized curves and does not explicitly identify them with this HRE-free formulation. |
| CIBAS REN52SH, Pure | The [June 2026 catalog](https://cibasgroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/CIBAS-Sintered-NdFeB-Jun26-150626.pdf), page 2, offers a Pure configuration excluding Dy/Tb/Ho/Gd through REN52SH. Its graphic distinguishes offered grades from grades under development. | The catalog also uses a general HRE-free concentration description below 0.1%. Exact elemental limits, hot finished-part performance, lot guarantees, lead time and production origin require confirmation. The separate Ho/Gd configuration is only Dy/Tb-free. |

Neither document qualifies the complete joint requirement. Neither supports assigning a hot curve to an unmeasured research specimen. Missing public guarantees alone do not establish a material-development opportunity. HRE-free chemistry, domestic production, finished-part performance and procurement compliance are different questions.

## The stronger control in the retained calculations

At the same assumed remanence and directly matched torque, the original-thickness magnet with the alternative generic-steel law needs less current. Resizing copper to hold copper loss fixed leaves about 5.1 g less modeled copper. Thinning the magnet with the same steel law leaves about 2.5 g less rotor-and-copper mass. The underlying values remain in [equal_torque_all_five.csv](equal_torque_all_five.csv) and [direct_equal_torque_ledger.csv](direct_equal_torque_ledger.csv).

With the original winding retained, the original-thickness/ring change instead reduces copper loss by about 19 W at the 20 °C reference resistance, with no direct mass saving. Copper removal and that loss reduction are alternative uses of the improvement. Equal copper loss is not equal hotspot temperature or transient capacity.

The steel laws are assumptions, not qualified ring materials. Density, strength, manufacturing stress, magnetic loss, retention and cooling remain consequential. Zero or negative installed benefit remains possible. A motor already using an appropriate ring may have no such opportunity.

## The decision this changes

Identify the required duty, protection behavior and worthwhile installed saving. Compare available finished parts and the ring-and-winding option. If a useful design still depends on an unmet magnetic requirement, a hot same-batch parent/finished-part comparison can locate a shortfall. Separate tests would then be needed to distinguish finishing damage, magnetization, coating, microstructure and assembly effects.

The nominal 6 mT specimen margin is smaller than its plot-reading resolution and sits above a conditional zero-saving line. It is not an instrument specification. Measurement design must account for the complete uncertainty and the size of the useful installed benefit.

## Sources and reuse

The linked supplier PDFs are publicly accessible, but no open redistribution license is asserted. They are not bundled or redrawn. This update contains attributed factual summaries and links. The historical supplier observations retain the original science package's source-rights record. The current supplier offers are not added to the hot-property plot because comparable hot finished-part data have not been established.
